Anthony Michael Hall, Mario Cantone, and Loni Love

1 Jason Alexander, Michael Mizanin, and Cheryl Burke 2 Andy Richter, Vanilla Ice, and Caroline Rhea 3 Donny Osmond, Jeff Garlin, and Amber Riley 4 Melissa Joan Hart, Tituss Burgess, and Lacey Chabert 5 Anthony Michael Hall, Mario Cantone, and Loni Love 6 Joey Fatone, Wanya Morris, and Shawn Stockman 7 Vivica A. Fox, Michelle Trachtenberg, and Jason Mraz 8 Nia Vardalos, Jodie Sweetin, and John Michael Higgins 9 James Pickens, Jr., Brooke Burns and Johnny Weir 10 Tara Lipinski, Raven-Symoné and Tori Spelling 11 Marcia Cross, Karl-Anthony Towns and Anthony Anderson 12 Curtis Stone, Haley Joel Osment and Tatyana Ali 13 Von Miller, Ali Wentworth and Laverne Cox